Perkins v 34 215 St, LLC

2026 NY Slip Op 06154

October 21, 2026

Appellate Division, Second Department

Published by New York State Law Reporting Bureau pursuant to Judiciary Law § 431.

This decision is uncorrected and subject to revision before publication in the Official Reports.

Edward Perkins, respondent,

v

34 215 St, LLC, et al., defendants, Equity Settlement Services, Inc., et al., appellants.

Supreme Court of the State of New York, Appellate Division, Second Judicial Department

Decided on October 21, 2026

2025-01384, (Index No. 708779/15)

Mark C. Dillon, J.P.

Paul Wooten

Lourdes M. Ventura

Lisa S. Ottley, JJ.

Solomon & Siris, P.C., Garden City, NY (Bill Tsevis of counsel), for appellants.

Gemelli Gross Shapiro & Marino, Forest Hills, NY (John A. Gemelli of counsel), for respondent.

[*1]

DECISION & ORDER

In an action, inter alia, to recover damages for negligence, the defendants Equity Settlement Services, Inc., and Nick Vitucci appeal from an order of the Supreme Court, Queens County (Mojgan Cohanim Lancman, J.), dated November 19, 2024. The order, insofar as appealed from, denied those branches of the motion of the defendants Old Republic National Title Insurance Company, Equity Settlement Services, Inc., Nick Vitucci, and Michael Ward which were for summary judgment dismissing the eighth cause of action asserted against the defendant Nick Vitucci and the ninth cause of action insofar as asserted against the defendants Equity Settlement Services, Inc., and Nick Vitucci to the extent those causes of action sought to recover for damage to real and personal property and the removal of copper piping.

ORDERED that the ordered is reversed insofar as appealed from, on the law, with costs, and those branches of the motion of the defendants Old Republic National Title Insurance Company, Equity Settlement Services, Inc., Nick Vitucci, and Michael Ward which were for summary judgment dismissing the eighth cause of action asserted against Nick Vitucci and the ninth cause of action insofar as asserted against the defendants Equity Settlement Services, Inc., and Nick Vitucci to the extent those causes of action sought to recover for damage to real and personal property and the removal of copper piping are granted.

On June 12, 2015, an individual (hereinafter the imposter), who falsely held himself out as the plaintiff, appeared at a closing for a purported sale of certain real property located in Bayside (hereinafter the property), which was owned by the plaintiff, to the defendant 34 215 St, LLC (hereinafter the LLC). At the closing, the defendant Nick Vitucci, a notary public and title closer for the defendant Equity Settlement Services, Inc. (hereinafter Equity), reviewed a driver's license presented by the imposter as identification and notarized the imposter's signature on a deed and a mortgage issued in connection with the purported sale.

In August 2015, the plaintiff commenced this action, inter alia, to quiet title against, among others, the LLC. In the amended complaint, the plaintiff asserted, among other things, causes of action to recover damages for negligence and notarial misconduct against, among others, Equity, Vitucci, Michael Ward, the manager of Equity's recording department, and Old Republic National [*2]Title Insurance Company (hereinafter Old Republic), which issued a policy of title insurance to the LLC as the purported purchaser of the property. The amended complaint alleged, inter alia, that Vitucci engaged in notarial misconduct by notarizing the imposter's signature on the fraudulently issued deed and mortgage, that Vitucci and Equity, among others, negligently caused the deed and mortgage to be recorded, and that those defendants' conduct resulted in damages to the plaintiff. The amended complaint also alleged that the plaintiff's damages included damage to real and personal property and the removal of copper piping by the defendant Newton Procopio, the sole member of the LLC.

Thereafter, Vitucci, Equity, Ward, and Old Republic (hereinafter collectively the moving defendants) moved for summary judgment dismissing the amended complaint insofar as asserted against them. In an order dated November 19, 2024, the Supreme Court, among other things, denied those branches of the moving defendants' motion which were for summary judgment dismissing the eighth cause of action, alleging notarial misconduct, asserted against Vitucci and the ninth cause of action, alleging negligence, insofar as asserted against Equity and Vitucci to the extent those causes of action sought to recover for damage to real and personal property and the removal of copper piping from the property. Equity and Vitucci appeal.

On their motion for summary judgment, the moving defendants established, prima facie, that Vitucci, in his capacity as the notary at the closing, complied with his statutory obligations to verify the identity of the parties (see Real Property Law § 303; 19 NYCRR 182.5[b][1][i]-[iv]). In opposition, the plaintiff, who failed to submit evidence that the identification presented by the imposter was obviously false or should have put Vitucci on notice that the identification might be false, failed to raise a triable issue of fact (see Countrywide Home Loans, Inc. v United Gen. Tit. Ins. Co., 109 AD3d 953, 954). Accordingly, the Supreme Court should have granted those branches of the moving defendants' motion which were for summary judgment dismissing the eighth and ninth causes of action insofar as asserted against Vitucci in their entirety.

A "'title company hired by one party is not, absent evidence of fraud, collusion, or other special circumstances, subject to suit for negligent performance by one other than the party who contracted for its services'" (Velazquez v Decaudin, 49 AD3d 712, 716, quoting Calamari v Grace, 98 AD2d 74, 83; see Sabo v Alan B. Brill, P.C., 25 AD3d 420, 421). Here, the moving defendants established Equity's prima facie entitlement to judgment as a matter of law dismissing the cause of action to recover damages for negligence insofar as asserted against Equity by demonstrating, prima facie, that Equity was not aware the purported seller was not the plaintiff and that Equity did not act negligently. In opposition, the plaintiff, who did not allege that he had any relationship with Equity, failed to raise a triable issue of fact. Accordingly, the Supreme Court should have granted that branch of the moving defendants' motion which was for summary judgment dismissing the ninth cause of action insofar as asserted against Equity in its entirety.

The parties' remaining contentions either need not be reached in light of our determination or are without merit.

DILLON, J.P., WOOTEN, VENTURA and OTTLEY, JJ., concur.

ENTER:

Darrell M. Joseph

Clerk of the Court